19 Sep This is Why Everyone’s Googling September 23rd
“This is Why Everyone’s Googling September 23rd”
Written by Logan Martinez Edited by Craig Groshek Thumbnail Art by Craig Groshek Narrated by N/ACopyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on CreepypastaStories.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed, adapted to film, television or audio mediums, republished in a print or electronic book, reposted on any other website, blog, or online platform, or otherwise monetized without the express written consent of its author(s).
🎧 Available Audio Adaptations: None Available
⏰ ESTIMATED READING TIME — 12 minutes
I didn’t know why everyone was Googling September 23rd, but I do now. I wish I hadn’t found out.
My name is Oren Pierce. I write about fringe culture and the ways people convince themselves the sky is falling. That was the plan last week when I started a piece about “apocalypse dates” people recycle every few years—numerology threads, meme calendars, prophecies with fresh coats of paint. This time, every road led to the same square on the map: September 23rd.
I didn’t come at it as a believer. I opened a dozen tabs, rolled my eyes at the thumbnails, and took notes. Clip the claims, trace the sources, follow the money. Most of it was noise—bits of scripture cut from their context, grainy photos of red calves, tourists filming men with ram’s horns on rooftops.
The first turn came from a dead link. An old blog referenced a channel I couldn’t find. I pushed it through an archive and landed on a mirror I won’t post here. The banner was a still of the Temple Mount at dusk. The title read: “Edison Whitney — Last Messages.” The uploads stopped two years ago.
Whitney wasn’t the foaming type. He spoke like a schoolteacher who stayed after class. In one clip, he broke down Rosh Hashanah, the Feast of Trumpets, and the hundred blasts that close it. He said the day wasn’t just symbolic; it was a mechanism—a key turned at a particular moment in a lock most of us pretend isn’t there. He didn’t name a rapture or sell canned food. He just asked viewers to pay attention to a sequence that would begin “when the horn is sounded and the world agrees to listen.” I paused the video and wrote the line down, not because I believed him, but because it was cleaner than most. Yet it sat in my notes like a thumbprint.
Another clip provided a careful explanation of a “perfect animal,” the red heifer, and why certain people would go quiet once they had one. Another featured patient language about a house of worship that wasn’t supposed to be built and the person who would stand in it. He sounded tired. He said he’d be gone for a while and hoped someone else would keep the receipts.
So I did what I do. I hunted for receipts.
Most forums were parodies of themselves. But in a corner of the web that still looks hand-coded, I found a thread that didn’t read like theater. Users traded file hashes and timestamps. They referenced agricultural registries and construction permits in a tone so dry it felt bureaucratic. The thread title was a date: September 23rd.
That’s where I first saw the username “BuddyBrown.” I figured it was a joke, somebody playing country bumpkin to cut the tension. He tossed off a few gas-station one-liners and then posted a set of coordinates. “Public land,” he wrote. “You didn’t hear it from me.”
I told myself I was logging it for later. I had a draft to file, a neat takedown of date-cults and the people who start them. But Whitney’s voice kept replaying, the way a lecturer’s does when the room is empty and you’re still copying the last sentence. I queued up another clip, and another. The pattern felt less like theater and more like someone marking trail blazes through a forest you think you know.
If you’re listening to this for entertainment, fine. But that’s not why I’m writing. This is a warning. I started with a smirk and a checklist. I’m ending this part without either. September 23rd isn’t trending because people are bored. It’s trending because something reached out of the background and touched the dials.
I’ll tell you what I found next. For now, remember the name Edison Whitney, and remember the thread titled with a date and a set of coordinates. If you think you can watch the trumpet videos and laugh, go ahead. I laughed, too. Then I wrote the line down. Then I stopped laughing.
If any of this sounds familiar—if you’ve seen that banner, if you’ve heard that voice—don’t share links. Save what you have. Back it up. I don’t think the original files will stay up much longer, and I don’t think the people who posted them are the ones taking them down.
* * * * * *
I thought Edison Whitney was just another online preacher, the kind who lived off fear and PayPal donations, but the more I watched, the less I could shake him. He spoke about the Feast of Trumpets with the precision of a historian and the dread of a man who expected to be proved right.
The Feast, he explained, isn’t some metaphor. It’s Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, and it always ends the same way, with one hundred blasts of the shofar. Whitney leaned toward the camera and said, “It isn’t for pageantry. It’s for alignment. When the hundredth blast echoes across the earth, the lock is open. The only question is what comes through.”
For my part, I remained convinced it was, in fact, just a metaphor. Still, I started noticing chatter in the places Whitney’s old clips pointed me toward. An article about a Jerusalem ceremony went offline two hours after it was published. Screenshots circulated in private groups: a stage being built, horn players rehearsing, cameras already in place.
That was when I heard from Chastity Wyatt.
Chastity wasn’t a doomsday type. She was an academic, someone I’d met while fact-checking a piece about biblical archeology years ago. Her reputation was for tearing down conspiracy theories, not building them up, so when her name landed in my inbox, I clicked immediately.
The subject line was blunt: “Don’t laugh this off.”
The body contained only a download link and the words: “It’s already happened.”
The files were dry—spreadsheets and scanned letters from Israeli agricultural agencies. I could barely read half the stamps, but one column jumped out: unblemished calf / red designation / status: removed from public registry. The dates lined up with when forum posts went quiet.
I tried to write back. The email bounced. Her account had been shut down.
While I was still staring at the error message, a notification pinged from the old forum thread. The user with the folksy name—BuddyBrown—had replied to me directly.
“City boy,” he wrote, “you’re chasing real fire now. Watch your eyebrows.”
I asked what he meant. His next message came with a link to a livestream of a rural synagogue I’d never heard of. The footage was grainy, but I could see tables stacked with horns, and a number of men in prayer shawls moving chairs into place.
“End of the Feast,” Buddy typed. “Hundred horns. Whole world watching. You’ll see.”
I typed back something sarcastic, something about him sounding like a character from a bad country song. He replied: “Careful. I was there when they brought the calf in. I know the sound it made.”
I sat with that. At first I thought it was a joke, but I couldn’t shake the image of an animal making a sound so unnatural a man like him couldn’t describe it straight.
I looked back at Whitney’s videos. He’d used almost the same words: “When the sacrifice is made, it will not sound like it came from this world.”
That’s when I stopped thinking of it as research and started calling it what it was: evidence.
Chastity was gone. Whitney was gone. And Buddy Brown, whoever he really was, had just told me he’d seen something no one was supposed to see.
I left the tabs open on my desktop. I should have closed them.
I should have closed all of it.
* * * * * *
The files from Chastity and the livestream from Buddy should have been enough for me to step back. I didn’t. Instead, I went further.
I dug into archived agricultural registries, chasing the trail Chastity had hinted at. The red heifers weren’t myth. They were catalogued—genetically monitored, exported, and then… scrubbed. Entire columns of data were marked “restricted.” Some entries simply vanished. The timestamps matched the weeks when chatter on the forums had gone dark.
Whitney had warned about this exact silence in one of his final recordings. “When the record-keepers close their books, it isn’t because the animals are gone. It’s because they’re no longer animals.”
That line stayed with me as I followed the threads deeper into the Brotherhood’s forums. Their language shifted from playful to coded. Numbers, coordinates, fragments of scripture, countdowns formatted like military orders. One post was nothing but an image: the foundation stone of the Temple Mount overlaid with the number 923 in dripping red text.
And then I found the video.
It wasn’t polished. It was grainy and handheld, as though filmed through a shirt sleeve. At first, it looked like any midnight vigil, depicting men in white garments, with their heads bowed. A calf, perfectly red, stood tethered in the center. For a moment, it seemed docile. Then the camera jolted, and a noise rose that I can’t describe properly. It wasn’t a bellow or a scream. It was too high, too human, too layered, like three voices inside one throat. The men dropped to their knees, and the feed cut.
I wanted to believe it was a hoax. But seconds later, my inbox pinged. I’d received a private message from Buddy Brown:
“Told you, son. That weren’t no barnyard noise. I was there. Stood at the back, thought I could stomach it. I ain’t slept right since.”
I called him reckless and asked why he’d gone. His reply came minutes later:
“Curiosity. Same as you. You think you’re just looking. Then you realize you’ve already stepped over the line.”
Buddy wasn’t joking anymore. His folksy tone had drained out of him. He typed like a man warning his own son.
That night, the disturbances began.
At 9:23 exactly, my kitchen clock stopped. The second hand froze, though the batteries were new. My laptop glitched, the time stamps on saved files all flipped to 09/23, regardless of the date. And then came the sound. It was faint at first, like a distant trumpet, but it grew stronger until I stood at the window, half-expecting to see a marching band in the street, but there was nothing but shadows. Shadows that seemed to hold too long to the ground, as though stretched by something unseen.
I tried to sleep, but it proved elusive. Every time I closed my eyes, I saw the calf’s mouth open again, its throat splitting into that impossible cry.
The next morning, I checked the forums. Dozens of posts had vanished, stealthily removed by. Whether by mods or someone else, I had no idea. And a single new thread had appeared, with the title: “Third Temple ready. Watch UN. September 22nd.”
I stared at the screen, hearing Whitney’s weary voice in my head: “When the Temple rises, it will not be the Messiah who enters, but the one who mimics Him. The world will bow, not knowing they are bowing to the wrong throne.”
For the first time, I believed him.
And I realized: if the rumors were true, then September 23rd wasn’t a meme. It was a deadline.
* * * * * *
The United Nations conference fell on September 22nd, and for once, I wasn’t watching ironically. Every major outlet streamed the event. Leaders took the stage one by one, their speeches filled with the usual calls for peace, climate action, and economic cooperation. But woven through was something different, something uncanny.
They all used the same phrase: “Unity under one leader.”
Different languages, different accents, but the exact same words. Some stumbled as though they hadn’t meant to say it. Others leaned into the phrase like they’d been rehearsing it all year. My stomach turned. I tried to brush it off as a translation error, a scripting mishap. But then I remembered Edison Whitney’s old line: “When the nations speak as one, it will not be for peace, but for surrender.”
That night, I felt it before I heard it. It began as a vibration, like a truck idling loudly outside. The glassware in my cabinet rattled. Then the air seemed to flex, and suddenly the power cut out. Every screen flickered, every device beeping awake on its own.
I wasn’t the only one who noticed. The forums lit up with panicked posts. People described the same thing: homes shuddering, lights dying, air vibrating. Some claimed they saw the sky split in streaks of crimson; others swore they heard trumpets overhead. I thought of the heifer’s scream.
My inbox pinged again. I’d received a message from a new address, with no subject line and just one sentence: “It has begun. Everything is under control. Do not resist.”
The phrase chilled me. It reminded me of the definition Whitney had once given for meekness in his Psalm sermons. Then, it had been a comfort. Now it sounded like a threat.
I went outside to find the neighborhood full of people, but not in the usual way. They weren’t chatting or rushing to their cars. They were walking in the same direction, all of them silent and glassy-eyed. Families, teenagers, and businessmen still in their ties were all headed downtown like sleepwalkers.
That’s when I saw her. Chastity Wyatt. She was in the crowd, her hair unkempt, her eyes blank. Her mouth moved, not quite chanting, not quite whispering, forming syllables I couldn’t decipher. She didn’t see me. She didn’t see anything.
I shouted her name, but she didn’t even flinch. Then the mass swallowed her, moving with purpose I couldn’t understand.
My phone buzzed in my hand. It was a voicemail notification, from Buddy Brown.
His voice trembled. “It’s happening, son,” he said. “Strength under control. Don’t fight it. Don’t fight…” His breath caught, and the message ended.
I called him back, and the line went straight to voicemail. I tried again and again, with no luck.
By then, the trumpet sounds had returned. By this time, they were no longer faint, nor distant, but everywhere. They rolled across the sky, not like music but like pressure waves, bending glass and rattling my bones. And still the people walked, arms swinging in unison, toward the city center.
I didn’t follow. I couldn’t. Instead, I locked my door, sat at my desk, and stared at Whitney’s final video playing on loop. He had been right, about all of it.
And the worst part? It was only September 22nd.
* * * * * *
I’m telling this as fast as I can, because the longer I wait, the more the signal drowns everything else out. If this reaches you in time, don’t argue with it. Don’t go to the window when you hear it. Don’t follow anyone anywhere. Stay put. Lock what you can. Unplug what you can’t.
You wanted proof. I wanted it, too. Tonight I got more than I asked for.
After the UN stream cut to highlights, a new link started bouncing through the forums and private chats. There was no watermark, no network bug, just a bare embed with a single line beneath it: Temple Mount – Live.
The camera faced the esplanade from an angle I didn’t recognize, high but not aerial. It was nighttime there, everything bathed in a sterile, colorless light. The crowd was silent, everyone standing shoulder to shoulder. People lifted their phones without recording, holding them up like offerings. Not one person opened their mouth.
The audio carried the wind and something else—something low and pulsing, like breath filtered through a tunnel. The chat beside the stream scrolled until it froze. A single system message replaced the usernames: COMMENTS DISABLED.
That’s when the procession stepped into the light. Men in white garments formed a corridor, and shortly after, someone crossed through them. The figure didn’t walk so much as glide, each step too smooth, as if the ground rose to meet the foot. The face was a smear of brightness, not from overexposure—the rest of the frame was sharp—but from something that refused to resolve. Where eyes should have been, there were glowing, flickering points, like heated metal or fireplace embers.
My speakers popped, and the sound shifted. If you’ve ever heard a shofar, you know it’s rough and earthy. This wasn’t. This was the idea of a trumpet, carried on the air with authority. Across the city, another answered it, and another, until the tones stacked into a merciless din.
I tried to screen-capture, only to have the software crash. My phone rebooted itself twice.
In the crowd, a woman swayed. When the figure turned, the light hit her face. Chastity. She was smiling the way people smile in old paintings, serene and emptied of self. Her lips moved in silence, murmuring incantations no one could hear.
The figure raised a hand, and every head dipped by the same degree at the same time. I heard many voices speak one word, nothing I understood.
Someone near a microphone began to chant. The voice was rough and familiar. It took me a few beats to place it because it didn’t sound like message-board folksiness anymore.
Buddy Brown.
He stood close to the dais. He didn’t look possessed. He looked obedient. He looked relieved. He moved his mouth with everyone else, matching the cadence exactly, and when the camera panned, his voice followed from one speaker to the next as if the sound were in the air rather than in him.
I shouted anyway. “Buddy! Stop!” He couldn’t hear me.
The chat flickered on for a handful of seconds, enough for the same sentence to appear in a dozen languages: DO NOT RESIST. Then it blinked out. The stream tightened its shot. It went where it was told.
Behind the procession, scaffolding rose like ribs. The camera tracked a polished foundation stone boxed in glass and ringed by equipment that hummed hard enough to buzz the audio. Men in suits stood off to the side. They weren’t leading anything. They were witnessing.
I kept thinking of Edison Whitney, of the exhausted patience he displayed in his last videos. He never begged or threatened. He just said, “When the house is raised, the wrong king will come to sit.” I had laughed then. I wasn’t laughing anymore.
Another blast rolled through my apartment, rattling the nearby glass. The floor buckled, pressing back against my feet. The stream jumped. A title card, white text on black, flashed for less than a second. I rewound frame by frame until it held: STRENGTH UNDER CONTROL.
When the picture returned, the figure stood before the stone, the light bending around it, and lifted both its hands. The crowd gave a cry that was equal parts joy and terror. I recognized the shape of that sound from the barnyard video. The heifer had taught them the note.
My living room dimmed, though every lamp was on. The trumpet pressure thickened. For a minute, I looked out my window at the people in the street and back at the screen, and the motion matched, as if everything everywhere were taking cues from a single source.
You’re expecting me to say the rapture came. It didn’t. No one disappeared. No graves opened. No choirs tore the sky. Instead, the world lowered its eyes.
A system chime rang from my speakers. The stream cut to a slate that said: SERVICE COMPLETE. The embed collapsed into plain text: You saw what you needed to see.
Outside, the line of walkers thinned, peeling off in even intervals, the way a stadium empties.
I don’t know how long this will stay up. I don’t know how much of what I saved will survive the next scrub. Maybe you were in one of those crowds. Maybe you remember it as a vigil, a ceremony, a civic thing you agreed to attend without thinking. If so, listen to me.
The date wasn’t a meme. The sacrifice wasn’t a rumor. The Temple isn’t a tourist piece anymore. The pressure you felt wasn’t in your head. The leader they’re talking about is not the one you’re thinking of.
When you hear the trumpet, you’ll understand. And by then, it’ll be too late.
🎧 Available Audio Adaptations: None Available
Written by Logan Martinez Edited by Craig Groshek Thumbnail Art by Craig Groshek Narrated by N/A🔔 More stories from author: Logan Martinez
Publisher's Notes: N/A Author's Notes: N/AMore Stories from Author Logan Martinez:
Related Stories:
You Might Also Enjoy:
Recommended Reading:
Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on CreepypastaStories.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed, adapted to film, television or audio mediums, republished in a print or electronic book, reposted on any other website, blog, or online platform, or otherwise monetized without the express written consent of its author(s).



